• Authorities censor, jail journalists to silence coverage of the royal family.
• Politicized courts issue heavy defamation awards.
100,000: Copies of two weeklies destroyed by authorities because they carried a poll about the king.
As King Mohammed VI marked his first decade on the Alawite throne, his government moved aggressively to censor coverage of the royal family and silence other critical news reporting, fueling deep concern about the future of independent journalism in this North African nation.
THE PRESS: 2009
• Main Index
MIDDLE EAST and NORTH AFRICA
• Regional Analysis:
Human rights coverage spreads despite government pushback
• Israel, Occupied Palestinian Territories
• Other developments
Reporting even positive
news about the 46-year-old monarch, portrayed as liberal-minded in 1999 when he
succeeded his father, King Hassan II, prompted retaliation. On August 1,
authorities destroyed more than 100,000 copies of Nichane, an Arabic-language weekly, and Tel Quel, its French-language
sister, both of which carried a public opinion poll in which 91 percent of
respondents said they viewed the king favorably. Three days later, the government
banned an issue of the French daily Le
Monde that also carried the
poll results. “Conducting a survey, the main focus of which is to ask the
citizens to give their thoughts on the king’s actions is in itself a violation
of the principles and the foundation of the royal system,” Minister of
Communication Khalid Naciri told reporters. “In
Critical scrutiny of the royal family has been effectively criminalized. The notorious 2002 Press Law allows the government to ban local or foreign papers found to “harm Islam, the monarchy, territorial integrity, or public order.” Twenty-six separate articles call for prison penalties for journalistic activities considered offensive, but insulting the royal family is especially risky, with potential punishment of three to five years in prison. Under the constitution, the king is “sacred and inviolable.”
Authorities used those legal tools to obstruct and delay distribution of the July 15 issue of Le Monde, and to ban the July 9-15 issue of the French weekly Le Courrier International, news reports said. Le Monde carried an opinion piece by Aboubakr Jamaï, former editor of the critical Moroccan weekly Le Journal Hebdomadaire, in which he characterized the king’s press policy as a “war against independent journalism.” The banned issue of Le Courrier International reprinted an article on the monarch’s personal wealth that initially ran in Le Journal Hebdomadaire. The piece was accompanied by an editorial cartoon calling Mohammed VI “the richest king of the poor!”
Questions about the
king’s health were taboo. In October, a
In September, police shut
Moroccan courts have often been used to settle scores with critical journalists, CPJ research shows. In its annual report released in June, the Moroccan Association for Human Rights said the courts were being used routinely to punish critical journalists and that trials related to freedom of expression were typically “unfair and politically motivated.” One case typified the perverse execution of justice.
Al-Jarida al-Oula was assessed fines of more than 350,000 dirhams (US$43,000) in early year in connection with two defamation complaints filed by an executive for a pro-government newspaper. Khalil Hachemi Idrissi, publishing director of the French-language Aujourd’hui Le Maroc, had objected to Al-Jarida al-Oula’s coverage of a 2008 episode in which a royal in-law was accused of shooting a traffic officer. Idrissi’s paper called Al-Jarida al-Oula unpatriotic and unethical for covering a case that was otherwise ignored in the press. When Al-Jarida al-Oula retorted that it had “no lesson in ethics to learn” from Idrissi’s paper, the executive took the matter to court, claiming he and the judiciary had been insulted. In addition to the monetary penalties, Anouzla and Al-Jarida al-Oula columnist Jamal Boudouma each received suspended prison sentences.
On July 10, more than 20 dailies and weeklies withheld editorials to protest court decisions imposing heavy defamation damages against local publications. In an accompanying statement, the Moroccan Federation of Newspaper Editors denounced what it called “blind judicial escalation” against critical newspapers.
The most outrageous of the
verdicts was issued in June when a
Le Journal Hebdomadaire, a leading government critic, was dealt a
potentially crippling blow in court. On September 30, the Supreme Court upheld
a 2006 ruling that ordered the weekly to pay damages of 3 million dirhams
(US$354,000) in a defamation case filed by Claude Moniquet, head of the
Brussels-based European Strategic Intelligence and
In July, CPJ wrote to the
king to express grave concerns about “the continued use of the courts to
suppress freedom of expression.” CPJ also wrote to U.S. Secretary of State
Hillary Rodham Clinton in October to urge her to “impress upon Moroccan
authorities that a free press is a crucial component of any free society.”