August 6, 2002
Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba
Prime Minister’s Office
Singh Durbar
Kathmandu, Nepal
Via facsimile: +997 1 227286
Your Excellency:
The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) condemns the recent detention of Kishor Shrestha, editor of the Nepali-language weekly newspaper Jana Aastha. Although police claimed the detention was because of a July 31 article, CPJ believes that Shrestha’s arrest may have been intended to silence his newspaper’s reporting on the controversial case of Krishna Sen, a pro-Maoist editor who, according to Jana Aastha, was allegedly killed in police custody.
At around 5 p.m. on August 4, eight plainclothes police officers arrived at the Jana Aastha office in Kathmandu, according to Shrestha. He said the officers did not produce an arrest warrant and then forcibly dragged him from his office when he refused to accompany them.
Superintendent of Police Ram Chandra Khanal told the national daily Kathmandu Post later that evening that Shrestha had been arrested “for the news that appeared in Jana Aastha‘s last edition,” and threatened to charge him with either defamation or for violating the Public Offences Act. The article in question alleged that Khanal was involved in illegal activities unrelated to the Sen case.
The next day, August 5, Shrestha was released without charge following protests led by the Federation of Nepalese Journalists. As a condition of his release, he was required to sign a statement apologizing for using “an objectionable adjective inadvertently” to describe Khanal, according to the national English-language daily The Kathmandu Post.
However, Shrestha told CPJ that the threat of the defamation charge was only the pretext for his arrest. He said that during his detention, an interrogating officer warned him to stop reporting on the Krishna Sen case since Jana Aastha‘s allegations of police misconduct had “created many problems” for the police department.
In a June 26 article, Jana Aastha reported that Sen, former editor of the pro-Maoist newspapers Janadesh and Janadisha, was tortured and killed in police custody. Authorities had arrested Sen on May 20 and accused him of being among the senior leaders of the Maoist movement and of commanding rebel operations in Kathmandu.
Jana Aastha‘s account of his alleged killing, which was based on confidential sources and has not been independently confirmed, caused a scandal in Nepal that was worsened by your government’s refusal to comment on the issue. Although a special commission of inquiry appointed to investigate Sen’s disappearance submitted a report to the home minister last week, its findings have not been made public.
In a June 28 letter to Your Excellency about Sen’s case, CPJ reported that Shrestha has feared arrest since his paper broke the story.
As a nonpartisan organization of journalists dedicated to the defense of our colleagues worldwide, CPJ is alarmed by the continuing deterioration of press freedom conditions in Nepal. According to the Federation of Nepalese Journalists, more than 130 journalists have been arrested since your government imposed a state of emergency in November 2001 in response to intensified fighting by Maoist rebels. Under the state of emergency, press freedom and most other civil liberties ordinarily guaranteed by Nepal’s constitution have been suspended.
CPJ urges Your Excellency to ensure that journalists in Nepal can freely carry out their professional duties without fear of imprisonment. We ask again that your government provide details about the specific charges against the journalists still detained, and we renew our request for immediate information about Krishna Sen’s status.
We thank you for your attention to these urgent matters and await your response.
Sincerely,
Ann Cooper
Executive Director