Attacks, arrests, threats, censorship: The high risks of reporting the Israel-Gaza war

Al-Jazeera Gaza bureau chief Wael Al Dahdouh (center) mourns over the bodies of family members on October 26, 2023. The previous day, his wife, son, daughter, and grandson were killed in an Israeli airstrike on the Nuisserat refugee camp in the Gaza Strip. (Photo: AP/Ali Mahmoud)

Since the Israel-Gaza war began on October 7, journalists and media across the region have faced a hostile environment that has made reporting on the war exceptionally challenging.  

In addition to documenting the growing tally of journalists killed and injured, CPJ’s research has found multiple kinds of incidents of journalists being targeted while carrying out their work in Israel and the two Palestinian territories, Gaza and the West Bank.

These include 54 arrests, as well as numerous assaults, threats, cyberattacks, and censorship. As of September 6, CPJ’s records showed that 35 of these journalists were still under arrest.

(Editor’s note: These numbers are being updated regularly as more information becomes available.)

Several journalists have also lost family members while covering the war. Two examples are detailed below:

The Israeli prime minister’s office tweeted that the photographers were accomplices in “crimes against humanity” and Israeli war cabinet member Benny Gantz said they should be treated as terrorists. Major media outlets, including Reuters, rejected the claims and HonestReporting subsequently withdrew the accusations.

On November 13, eight members of Qudih’s family were killed when their house in southern Gaza was struck by four missiles.

In Gaza, 90% of the population has been displaced, many are starving, and 80% of buildings have been destroyed. Many journalists have no safe place to do their jobs as they live in tents and work from makeshift offices, such as hospitals, where they can access power.

In both Gaza and Israel, journalists reporting on the war lack personal protective equipment (PPE). CPJ has received multiple requests for PPE, but delivering this equipment to journalists in the region is difficult. CPJ recommends journalists consult CPJ’s PPE guide to source their own equipment.

“Journalists in Gaza are facing exponential risk,” said CPJ Program Director Carlos Martínez de la Serna. “Their colleagues in the West Bank and Israel are also facing unprecedented threats, assaults, and intimidation to obstruct their vital work covering this conflict.”

Here are some of the reported obstructions to journalists’ reporting since the war began:

Assaults

“When we arrived in the area, people were very angry. We went live on TV, when a group of about five men started obstructing us. We moved to another location in a nearby street but a group of men there obstructed us as well. Some were telling us to leave. I was beaten and kicked by about four men, and one of them broke our camera, with the mic and the material on it,” Tanios told CPJ, adding, “I feel sore in my head and back from the beating and kicking.”

Berry published a video on Instagram showing a man destroying the camera and MTV Lebanon published a video of the journalist being attacked.

Tanios said that his lawyer would file a lawsuit against the attackers.

Dahiyeh is seen as a Hezbollah stronghold. MTV Lebanon, a local channel privately owned by businessman Michel El Murr, is considered anti-Hezbollah. A post on its website accused Hezbollah supporters of conducting the assault.

Reporter Ilana Curiel of the Israeli news site Ynet reported that the protesters, who broke into the detention center in southern Israel, called her and other Israeli journalists traitors and Hamas supporters and told them to go back to Gaza.

“I’m in tears. I was spat on, called a slut, and unfaithful. My phone was thrown away twice while I was just trying to do my job. They tried to steal my phone. I was cursed again and again,” Curiel posted on X, formerly Twitter. A team from Channel 12 News, including correspondent Ori Isaac, were also hit, spat on and verbally abused, those sources said. Security officers helped Curiel and Isaac to safety; neither sustained serious injury.

A video of the incident, shot by Awad and reviewed by CPJ, shows soldiers hitting two men and pushing Awad away.

“An Israeli soldier came and put his hand on my camera, pushing it away from the scene,” Awad told CPJ. He added “Another pushed me forcefully and threw me to the ground, which led to my arm injury and the camera was also damaged.” 

Awad and Admeer told CPJ that the same soldiers checked their press cards three times before and during the incident.

Admeer said he started filming the attack on Awad on his phone but a soldier forced him to hand it over and deleted the footage. Admeer said he told the soldier, “I’m a journalist with accreditation,” but she responded, “I don’t care, go home.”

CPJ’s email to the Israeli Border Police seeking comment did not receive a response.

Journalists from Sky News Arabia, Firas Lutfi, and Raed El-Helw, who were previously assaulted on October 7, informed PJS that Israeli forces targeted them with tear gas and unidentified bullets while reporting from what they thought was a safe area, away from clashes in front of Ofer prison. They were wearing their media vests and informed the Israeli soldiers that they were members of the media. As a result of this attack, El-Helw was injured in his hand while trying to retrieve his camera and leave the area. El-Helw stated that it was a deliberate sniper attack on him and that he observed a laser light on his hand right before he was targeted. PJS shared footage of interviews with Lutfi and El-Helw, along with another video documenting El-Helw’s injury. PJS added that the crews of TRT and Roya News were present during the attack on the journalists.

In response, the Israeli police issued a statement, quoted by the BBC, that its officers noticed “a suspicious vehicle and stopped it for inspection” and searched the vehicle “for fear of possession of weapons.”

Threats

Gotliv accused Magadli of “helping the murderous Hamas” by revealing the location and intentions of Israeli soldiers. “He endangers our heroic fighters and our hostages,” Gotliv wrote, adding, “the penal code states that anyone assisting the enemy in times of war is sentenced to death or life imprisonment. I am tired of enemies at home!”

Previously, in a February tweet, Gotliv accused Magdali of disloyalty to Israel and expressing joy over the death of Jewish people on Channel 12’s “Meet the Press” program when he said, referring to the Israel-Gaza war, that if “we continue to gallop in this direction … there will really be a civil war between Jews and Arabs and the Arabs would win.”

In an August 27 response to Gotliv’s tweet, Magdali wrote on his Telegram account that “the next time you hear an MP talking about democracy and freedom of expression remind them of this explicit incitement to kill a person whose only crime is that he is an Arab journalist and writes in Arabic.”

Christian Limpert, the head of the ARD Tel Aviv studio, also called the incident as an attempt to obstruct ARD and other international media from reporting in the West Bank, according to Tagesschau and Haaretz.

After more than an hour, the situation eased when the IDF’s Foreign Desk, responsible for foreign correspondents, mediated by telephone. Haaretz reported that the IDF apologized and stated its commitment to ensuring freedom of the press in the West Bank. Limpert reported that days before this incident, soldiers detained an ARD cameraman and his soundman for two hours from reporting on settler violence near Qawawis in South Hebron. During that incident, their phones and camera were temporarily confiscated, according to Haaretz and the Foreign Press Association in Israel (FPA)’s statement.

CPJ’s emails requesting comment on these incidents from the IDF spokesperson for North America and the Israeli police did not receive any replies.

Cyberattacks

Censorship

In a video on Facebook, Karhi accused Al Mayadeen of being a “terrorist incitement platform” and called on the minister of defense to “announce it a terrorist organization.”

The decision came after Al Mayadeen reporter Hanaa Mahameed reported on a July 27 strike that in the town of Majdal Shams in the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights, which Israel captured from Syria in 1967. Israel and Hezbollah blamed each other for the attack.

Harassment

Rains posted photos and a videos of the incident on Instagram, in which one young man pulled a face, another stuck his tongue out, and a third spat and threw his drink at the journalists in the car, who were accompanied by Israeli activist Guy Hirshfield.

“While taking photographs and video of settlers bathing in a natural spring about 10 miles north of Jericho, our car … was attacked and our ability to work obstructed,” wrote Rains, 23, who recently started the Rains Report on Substack to publish his coverage of the region.

Rains told CPJ that it was his first interaction with settlers, on his third day in the West Bank, and that the team were fine as they drove off.

Anadolu Agency photographer Hisham Abu Shakra, Abu Dhabi-based Viory video news agency photographer Abed Alrahman Younis, and Palestine Post news site reporter Ayah Ramadan, and a fourth journalist who declined to be named told CPJ that they were reporting in the area at about 8:00 a.m. when three IDF vehicles stopped nearby and about 15 soldiers got out. The soldiers ordered the journalists to move and one soldier said, “Don’t film me.” The journalists responded that they were not filming and started walking away as instructed. The soldiers confiscated Younis’ camera, phone, and ID; Abu Shakra’s camera, tripod, and mics; and Ramadan’s ID.

The journalists then moved to stand by a building, waiting to get their equipment back, when four soldiers ran up to them with their guns raised, shouting. This time, they confiscated Ramadan’s phone, and the fourth journalist’s ID. Part of the incident was captured in a video by a surveillance camera, reviewed by CPJ. The journalists said the items were never returned, hindering their ability to move around freely and work.

CPJ’s email to the IDF’s North America desk seeking comment did not receive a response.

Escudero posted a video of the incident on social media, in which she said that the crowd threatened the journalists, spat on them, and shouted in unison that they were impure for wearing trousers.

“They wished us death. And, in the end, they decided to join forces to scare us and get us out of their neighborhood. They followed us and started throwing whatever they found in their path,” she wrote, adding that women also shouted down from the windows of buildings, calling the journalists impure and telling them to go away.

Lara told CPJ that she felt “somewhat overwhelmed by how the ultra-Orthodox citizens reacted” and by the response on social media to her post. “Many people have been attacking and recriminating me for having covered the demonstration as a woman. They say I went to provoke,” she said.

“While we were covering anti-war demonstrations in Tel Aviv, we were detained for two hours and prevented from working under the pretext that we are affiliated with Al Jazeera, which is banned in Israel, just because we spoke Arabic,” Dowani said. 

Footage of the incident shows Israeli police officers checking the journalists’ press cards and Darawsha holding a microphone with the logo of Al-Araby TV.  


More on journalist casualties in the Israel-Gaza conflict

See our safety resources for journalists covering conflict

Exit mobile version