|
EIGHTY-ONE JOURNALISTS WERE IN PRISON AROUND THE WORLD at the end of 2000,
jailed for practicing their profession. The number is down slightly from
the previous year, when 87 were in jail, and represents a significant
decline from 1998, when 118 journalists were imprisoned.
While jailing journalists can be an effective means of stifling bad press
at home, it is very costly in terms of a country's international image.
Particularly in Eastern Europe and Latin America, many countries use more
subtle methods to control the press—punitive tax laws, expensive libel
suits, and advertising boycotts. States that routinely jail journalists,
on the other hand, are often impervious to international criticism.
China, for example, had 22 journalists in jail at year's end, more than
any other country in the world. CPJ added four Chinese journalists to
the list this year based on new information, and documented one new China
case in 2000. As documented in CPJ's special report, The
Great Firewall, Chinese authorities have taken extraordinary measures,
including the jailing of seven Internet journalists, to suppress critical
journalism on the World Wide Web.
In previous years, the Chinese government made concessions to international
public opinion by carefully stage-managing the release of prominent dissidents,
including journalists, at critical moments. Authorities took a harder
line in 2000, when not a single journalist was released.
Three other perennial jailers are Burma, which held at least eight journalists
at year's end (the actual number is thought to be much higher), Ethiopia,
which held seven journalists, and Uzbekistan, which held three. Some of
the jailed Burmese journalists have been held for more than a decade,
and there was little new information about their cases in 2000. In Ethiopia,
meanwhile, authorities piled additional charges on journalists who were
already in jail, lengthening their sentences.
Three journalists were released from jail in Turkey, either provisionally,
on appeal, or after completing their sentences. A fourth, Erhan Il, who
was jailed in 1996, was no longer in prison, according to reliable sources
in Turkey. While Turkey continues to hold 14 journalists—an unconscionably
high number—the number has dropped significantly in recent years and is
expected to continue to decline as the remaining jailed journalists complete
their sentences. Meanwhile, new prosecutions were rare compared with previous
years.
Cuba, the only country in the Americas that regularly jails journalists,
held three at the end of 2000. One of them, Jesús Joel Díaz
Hernández, was released on January 17, 2001, after completing two
years of a four-year sentence on the uniquely Cuban charge of "dangerousness."
One important newcomer to the list is Iran, where six journalists were
imprisoned at year's end. The jailings were just one element in a systematic
campaign by Iran's clerical establishment to stamp out the reformist press,
which has persistently criticized conservative elements within the government
and called for change. Some 30 reformist newspapers were shut down in
2000, wiping out a vital source of alternative news and information.
In an interview at the beginning of 2001, jailed Iranian investigative
reporter Akbar Ganji said, "It is a great honor for a man to defend his
ideas against dictators." Ganji warned of an "explosion" if the crackdown
continued.
Our census of imprisoned journalists represents a snapshot of all the
journalists who were incarcerated when the clock struck midnight on December
31. It does not include the dozens of journalists who were imprisoned
and released during the year; accounts of those cases can be found in
the regional sections of this book. In Egypt, for example, the authorities
have jailed many journalists for libel under the punitive Press Law, but
the three journalists jailed in 2000 were all released before the end
of the year (a fourth Egyptian journalist, Hussein al-Mataani, was jailed
in 1999; he remains on our list because CPJ was unable to confirm whether
or not he had been released). Meanwhile, the four journalists jailed in
the Democratic Republic of Congo were all released in an amnesty on January
4, 2001, just weeks before President Laurent-Désiré Kabila
was murdered by one of his bodyguards.
There was scattered good news in 2000. Syria released five journalists,
some of whom had completed their sentences. Two more were amnestied by
President Bashar al-Asad, who has allowed local journalists to voice occasional,
mild criticisms of the government since he succeeded his late father in
June. At the same time, Syrian journalist and human-rights activist Nizar
Nayyouf remained in prison at year's end. Nayyouf has been jailed for
nine years and reportedly suffers from Hodgkin's disease and other ailments.
A word about how this list is compiled: In totalitarian societies where
independent journalism is forbidden, CPJ often defends persecuted writers
whose governments would view them as political dissidents rather than
journalists. This category would embrace the samizdat publishers of the
former Soviet Union and the wall-poster essayists of the pre-Tiananmen
period in China. We also include political analysts, human-rights activists,
and others who were prosecuted over their written or broadcast work. Because
such prosecutions threaten all working journalists, we defend these imprisoned
writers as colleagues.
CPJ also uses a broad definition of the term "imprisoned." We consider
all journalists held forcibly against their will by governments, guerrillas,
or kidnappers to be imprisoned. For example, we include two Algerian journalists,
Djamel Eddine Fahassi and Aziz Bouabdallah, who were apparently abducted
by government agents in 1995 and 1997, respectively. While there is no
information about their whereabouts, CPJ continues to hold the Algerian
government responsible for their fate.
At the end of the year, CPJ wrote to every head of state on the following
list, requesting information about jailed journalists in each country.
While CPJ does not include "missing" journalists on this list, we monitor
all such cases. For example, we continue to demand that Belarus account
for the disappearance of TV news cameraman Dimitry Zavadsky, who vanished
in July 2000.
ALGERIA: 2
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Abdel Aziz Bouteflika
President of the Democratic and Popular Republic of Algeria
c/o His Excellency Ambassador
Driss Djazairi
Embassy of the Democratic and Popular Republic of Algeria
2118 Kalorama Road N.W.
Washington, DC 20008
Fax: 202-667-2174
Djamel Eddine Fahassi, Alger Chaïne III
IMPRISONED: May 6, 1995
Fahassi, at the time a 41-year-old reporter for the state-run radio station
Alger Chaïne III and a contributor to several Algerian newspapers, including
the now-banned weekly organ of the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS), Al-Forqane,
was abducted near his home in the al-Harrache suburb of Algiers by four
well-dressed men carrying walkie-talkies. According to eyewitnesses who
later spoke with his wife, the men called out Fahassi's name and then
pushed him into a waiting car. He has not been seen since, and Algerian
authorities have denied any knowledge of his arrest.
Prior to his "disappearance," Fahassi was targeted by Algerian authorities
on at least two occasions in response to his published criticisms of the
government. In late 1991, he was arrested following the publication of
an article in Al-Forqane criticizing a raid conducted by security
forces on an Algiers neighborhood. On January 1, 1992, the Blida Military
Court convicted him of disseminating false information, attacking a state
institution, and disseminating information that could harm national unity.
He received a one-year suspended sentence and was released after five
months. On February 17, 1992, he was arrested a second time for allegedly
attacking state institutions and spreading false information. He was transferred
to the Ain Salah detention center in southern Algeria, where hundreds
of Islamist suspects were interned in the months following the cancellation
of elections in January 1992.
Aziz Bouabdallah, Al-Alam al-Siyassi
IMPRISONED: April 12, 1997
Three armed men abducted Bouabdallah, a 22-year-old reporter for the daily
Al-Alam al-Siyassi, from his home in the Chevalier section of Algiers.
According to Bouabdallah's family, the men stormed into their home and,
after identifying Bouabdallah, grabbed him, put his hands behind his back,
and pushed him out the door into a waiting car. An article published in
the daily El-Watan a few days after his abduction reported
that Bouabdallah was in police custody and was expected to be released
imminently. In July 1997, CPJ received credible information that Bouabdallah
was being held at the Châteauneuf detention facility in Algiers, where
he had been subjected to torture. Bouabdallah's whereabouts are currently
unknown. As in the case of Bouabdallah's colleague Djamel Eddine Fahassi,
authorities have denied any knowledge of his abduction.
BURMA: 8
Please send appeals to:
Senior General Than Shwe
c/o The Embassy of the Union of Myanmar,
2300 S Street, NW
Washington, D.C. 20008-4089
Fax: 202-332-9046
U Win Tin
IMPRISONED: July 4, 1989
U Win Tin, former editor of the daily Hanthawati and vice chairman
of Burma's Writers Association, was arrested and sentenced to three years
of hard labor. In 1992, the sentence was extended by 10 years. U Win Tin
was active in establishing independent publications during the 1988 student
democracy movement. He also worked closely with National League for Democracy
leader Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and was one of her closest advisers. On March
28, 1996, prison authorities extended U Win Tin's sentence by another
seven years, after they convicted him of smuggling letters describing
the horrific living conditions of inmates at Rangoon's Insein Prison to
Yozo Yokota, the United Nations special rapporteur for human rights in
Burma.
U Win Tin is said to be in extremely poor health after years of maltreatment
in Burma's prisons—including a period when he was kept in solitary confinement
in one of Insein Prison's notorious "dog cells," formerly used as a kennel
for the facility's guard dogs. He has told international observers that
he is suffering from spondylitis, a degenerative spine disease.
Maung Maung Lay Ngwe, Pe-Tin-Than
IMPRISONED: September 1990
Maung Maung Lay Ngwe was arrested and charged with writing and distributing
publications that "make people lose respect for the government." The publications
were entitled, collectively, Pe-Tin-Than ("Echoes").
Myo Myint Nyein and Sein Hlaing, What's Happening?
IMPRISONED: September 1990
Myo Myint Nyein and Sein Hlaing were arrested for contributing to the
preparation, planning, and publication of the satirical news magazine
What's Happening, which the Burmese government claimed was anti-government
propaganda. They were sentenced to seven years in prison. On March 28,
1996, they were among 21 prisoners tried inside Insein Prison and given
an additional seven-year sentence, under the Emergency Provisions Act,
for smuggling letters describing prison conditions to Yozo Yokota, the
United Nations special rapporteur for human rights in Burma.
Daw San San Nwe and U Sein Hla Oo, free-lancers
IMPRISONED: August 5, 1994
Dissident writer Daw San San Nwe and journalist U Sein Hla Oo were arrested
on charges of contacting anti-government groups and spreading information
damaging to the state. On October 6, 1994, they were sentenced to 10 years
and seven years in prison, respectively. Three other dissidents, including
a former UNICEF worker, received sentences of seven to 15 years in prison
on similar charges. Officials said the five had "fabricated and sent anti-government
reports" to diplomats in foreign embassies, foreign radio stations, and
foreign journalists. San San Nwe allegedly met two French reporters visiting
Burma in April 1993 and appeared in a video they produced about the Burmese
government. Both Daw San San Nwe and U Sein Hla Oo were previously imprisoned
for their involvement in the National League for Democracy, Burma's main
pro-democracy party.
Ma Myat Mo Mo Tun, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: August 1994
Ma Myat Mo Mo Tun, the daughter of imprisoned writer Daw San San Nwe,
was arrested in August 1994 and sentenced to seven years in prison for
spreading information injurious to the state. She was alleged to have
recorded "defamatory letters and documents," made contact with "illegal"
groups, and sent anti-government articles to a journal published by a
Burmese expatriate group.
Ye Htut, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: September 27, 1995
Ye Htut was arrested on charges of sending fabricated news to Burmese
dissidents and opposition media abroad and sentenced to seven years in
prison. Among the organizations to which Ye Htut allegedly confessed sending
reports was the Thailand-based Burma Information Group (BIG), which publishes
The Irrawaddy, a news magazine focusing on Burmese human-rights
issues. Burma's official media claimed that The Irrawaddy had presented
a false picture of the country to foreign governments and human-rights
organizations.
CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Ange Felix Patasse
President of the Central African Republic
Palais de la Presidence
Bangui, Central African Republic
Fax: 263-616-779
Raphaél Kopessoua, Vouma la Mouche
IMPRISONED: December 19, 2000
Managing editor Koupessoua of the private, pro-opposition weekly Vouma
La Mouche, has been in government custody on unspecified charges since
his arrest on December 19, 2000. The journalist was arrested while covering
a banned meeting of a dozen opposition parties at a stadium in the capital,
Bangui. More than 70 demonstrators were also arrested. Opposition parties
had called for a civil-disobedience movement starting December 19 to protest
overdue salary payment in the public administration, including the state
media.
In addition to his journalistic activities, Kopessoua is a union activist
and the local representative for the African Workers Union.
Kopessoua was released on January 8, 2001.
CHINA: 22
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Jiang Zemin
President, People's Republic of China
Beijing 100032
People's Republic of China
Fax: 86-10-6512-5810
Hu Liping, The Beijing Daily
IMPRISONED: April 7, 1990
Hu, a staff member of The Beijing Daily, was arrested and charged with
"counterrevolutionary incitement and propaganda" and "trafficking in state
secrets," according to a rare release of information on his case from
the Chinese Ministry of Justice in 1998. The Beijing Intermediate People's
Court sentenced him to a term of 10 years in prison on August 15, 1990.
Zhang Yafei, Tieliu
IMPRISONED: September 1990
Zhang, a former student at Beifang Communications University, was arrested
and charged with dissemination of counterrevolutionary propaganda and
incitement. In March 1991, he was sentenced to 11 years in prison and
two years without political rights after his release. Zhang edited Tieliu,
an underground publication about the 1989 crackdown at Tiananmen Square.
Chen Yanbin, Tieliu
IMPRISONED: September 1990
Chen, a former university student, was arrested in September 1990 and
sentenced in March 1991 to 15 years in prison and four years without political
rights after his release. He and Zhang Yafei ran Tieliu, an underground
publication about the 1989 crackdown at Tiananmen Square. Several hundred
mimeographed copies of Tieliu were distributed. The government
termed the publication "reactionary" and charged Chen with disseminating
counterrevolutionary propaganda and incitement. In September 2000, the
Justice Ministry announced that Chen's sentence was reduced by three months
for good behavior.
Liu Jingsheng, Tansuo
IMPRISONED: May 1992
Liu, a former writer and co-editor of the pro-democracy journal Tansuo,
was sentenced to 15 years in prison for "counterrevolutionary" activities
after being tried secretly in July 1994. Liu was arrested in May 1992,
and charged with being a member of labor and pro-democracy groups, including
the Liberal Democratic Party of China, the Free Labor Union of China,
and the Chinese Progressive Alliance. Court documents stated that Liu
was involved in organizing and leading anti-government and pro-democracy
activities. Prosecutors also accused him and other dissidents who were
tried on similar charges of writing and printing political leaflets that
were distributed in June 1992, during the third anniversary of the Tiananmen
Square demonstrations.
Kang Yuchun, Freedom Forum
IMPRISONED: May 1992
Kang disappeared on May 6, 1992, and was presumed arrested, according
to the New Yorkbased organization Human Rights Watch. In October 1993,
in response to an inquiry from the United Nations Working Group on Disappearances,
Chinese authorities said Kang was arrested on May 27, 1992. On July 14,
1994, he was one of 16 individuals tried in a Chinese court for their
alleged involvement with underground pro-democracy groups. Among the accusations
against Kang were that he had launched Freedom Forum, the magazine
of the Chinese Progressive Alliance, and commissioned people to write
articles for the magazine. On December 16, 1994, he was sentenced to 17
years in prison for "disseminating counterrevolutionary propaganda" and
for "organizing and leading a counterrevolutionary group."
Wu Shishen, Xinhua
Ma Tao, China Health Education News
IMPRISONED: November 6, 1992
Wu, an editor for China's state news agency Xinhua, was arrested for allegedly
leaking an advance copy of President Jiang Zemin's 14th Party Congress
address to a journalist from the Hong Kong newspaper Express. His
wife, Ma, editor of China Health Education News, was also arrested
on November 6, 1992, and accused of acting as Wu's accomplice. The Beijing
Municipal Intermediate People's Court held a closed trial, and on August
30, 1993, sentenced Wu to life imprisonment for "illegally supplying state
secrets to foreigners." Ma was sentenced to six years in prison. According
to the term of her original sentence, Ma should have been released in
November 1998, but CPJ has been unable to obtain information on her legal
status.
Hua Di, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: January 5, 1998
Hua, a permanent resident of the United States, was arrested while on
a visit to China and charged with revealing state secrets. The charge
is believed to stem from articles that Hua, a scientist at Stanford University,
had written about China's missile defense system.
On November 25, 1999, the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People's Court tried
Hua behind closed doors, and sentenced him to 15 years in prison, according
to the Hong Kong-based Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy.
In March 2000, the Beijing High People's Court nullified Hua's conviction
by the lower court and ordered the case to be retried. This judicial reversal
was extraordinary, particularly for a high-profile political case. Nevertheless,
in April, the Beijing State Security Bureau rejected a request for Hua
to be released on medical parole. Hua suffers from a rare form of male
breast cancer.On November 23, the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People's Court
issued a slightly modified verdict, sentencing Hua to 10 years in prison.
An appeal was filed on November 28, according to The New York Times.
News of Hua's sentencing broke in February 2001, when a relative gave the i
nformation to foreign correspondents based in Beijing.
Gao Qinrong, Xinhua
IMPRISONED: December 4, 1998
Gao, a reporter for the state news agency Xinhua, was jailed for reporting
on a corrupt irrigation scheme in drought-plagued Yuncheng, Shanxi Province.
Xinhua never carried Gao's article, which was finally published on May
27, 1998, in an internal reference edition of the official People's
Daily that is distributed only among a select group of Party leaders.
But by fall 1998, the irrigation scandal had become national news, with
reports appearing in the Guangzhou-based Southern Weekend ("Nanfang
Zhoumo") and on China Central Television (CCTV). Gao's wife, Duan Maoying,
said that local officials blamed Gao for the flurry of media interest,
and arranged for his prosecution on false charges. Gao was arrested on
December 4, 1998, and eventually charged with crimes including bribery,
embezzlement, and pimping, according to Duan. On April 28, 1999, he was
sentenced to 13 years in prison after a closed, one-day trial. He is being
held in a prison in Qixian, Shanxi Province, according to CPJ sources.
Yue Tianxiang, Guo Xinmin, China Workers' Monitor
IMPRISONED: January 1999
The Tianshui People's Intermediate Court in Gansu Province sentenced Yue
to 10 years in prison and Guo to two-years on July 5, 1999. The two journalists
were charged with "subverting state power," according to the Hong Kongbased
Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy. A third colleague,
Wang Fengshan, was also sentenced to two years imprisonment but was released
in August 2000, CPJ learned.
According to the South China Morning Post, Yue, Guo, and Wang were
arrested in January for publishing China Workers' Monitor, a journal
that campaigned for workers' rights.
With help from Wang, Yue and Guo started the journal after they were unable
to get compensation from the Tianshui City Transport agency following
their dismissal from the company in 1995. All three men were reportedly
members of the outlawed China Democracy Party, a dissident group, and
were forming an organization to protect the rights of laid-off workers.
The first issue of China Workers' Monitor exposed extensive corruption
among officials at the Tianshui City Transport agency. Only two issues
were reportedly ever published.
Wang Yingzheng, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: February 26, 1999
Police arrested Wang in the city of Xuzhou, in eastern Jiangsu Province,
as he was photocopying an article he had written about political reform.
The article was based on an open letter that the 19-year-old Wang had
addressed to China's President Jiang Zemin. In the letter, Wang wrote—as
translated in a report published by Agence France-Presse—"Many Chinese
are discontented with the government's inability to squash corruption.
This is largely due to a lack of opposition parties and a lack of press
freedom."
Wang was reportedly imprisoned for two weeks in September 1998 and questioned
about his association with Qin Yongmin, a key leader of the China Democracy
Party, who received a 12-year prison sentence in December 1998.
On December 10, 1999, Wang was convicted of subversion and sentenced to
three years in prison. His trial was closed to the public, but his family
was notified by letter of the verdict, according to the Hong Kongbased
Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy.
Liu Xianli, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: May 11, 1999
The Beijing Intermediate Court found writer Liu Xianli guilty of subversion
and sentenced him to four years in prison, according to a report by the
Hong Kongbased Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy.
Liu's putative "crime" was his attempting to publish a book on Chinese
dissidents, including Xu Wenli, one of China's most prominent political
prisoners and a leading figure in the China Democracy Party. In December
1998, Xu was himself convicted of subversion and sentenced to 13 years
in prison.
Jiang Qisheng, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: May 18, 1999
Police arrested Jiang late on the night of May 18, 1999, and searched
his home, seizing his computer, several documents, and articles he had
written for Beijing Spring, a New Yorkbased pro-democracy publication.
The arrest followed Jiang's publication of a series of essays and open
letters related to the 10th anniversary of the government's violent suppression
of student-led demonstrations in Tiananmen Square. One called for a candlelight
vigil on June 4, 1999, another urged the government to conduct a full
investigation into the massacre, and a third protested the police's brutal
treatment of Cao Jiahe, an editor of Orient magazine who was detained
on May 10, 1999, and tortured while in police custody. Cao was detained
for allegedly circulating a petition to remember the hundreds killed by
government troops during the Tiananmen crackdown.
Jiang, who had been a leader of the student demonstrations, spent 18 months
in jail following the 1989 crackdown, but continued to be outspoken on
political issues after his release. He wrote several articles for foreign
publications, such as Beijing Spring, and also issued open letters
that were circulated both within China and abroad.
During Jiang's two-and-a-half-hour-long trial, held on November 1, 1999,
prosecutors cited an April essay calling for a protest vigil, "Light a
Thousand Candles," as evidence of his anti-state activities. Prosecutors
also accused him of circulating an article by Li Xiaoping on political
reform, though Jiang said he showed the piece to only three friends.
On December 27, 2000, 13 months after his trial, the Beijing No. 1 Intermediate
People's Court sentenced Jiang to four years in prison. Jiang's lawyer
told journalists that the 13-month delay between the court's conviction
and sentencing "violated the legal process." In an open letter circulated
on January 6, 2001, by the New Yorkbased organization Human Rights in
China, four witnesses to the subversion trial said that testimony attributed
to them in the official verdict was fabricated.
Wu Yilong, Mao Qingxiang, Zhu Yufu, and Xu Guang, Opposition
Party
IMPRISONED: November 1999
Wu, an organizer for the banned China Democracy Party (CDP), was detained
by police in Guangzhou on April 26, 1999, according to the New Yorkbased
organization Human Rights Watch. Mao, Zhu, and Xu, also leading CDP activists,
were reportedly detained sometime around June 4, the 10th anniversary
of the brutal crackdown on pro-democracy demonstrations in Tiananmen Square.
The four were later charged with subversion for, among other things, establishing
a magazine called Opposition Party ("Zai Yedang") and circulating
pro-democracy articles and essays over the Internet.
On October 25, 1999, the Hangzhou Intermediate People's Court, in Zhejiang
Province, conducted what The New York Times described as a "sham
trial." Only two of the defendants were represented by a lawyer, whom
they shared. None of the accused were allowed to complete their testimony,
according to news reports.
The verdicts were not announced immediately. On November 9, 1999, the
Hong Kongbased Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy reported
that all four journalists had been convicted of subversion. Wu Yilong
was sentenced to 11 years in prison, one of the most severe sentences
imposed on a political prisoner in recent years. Mao Qingxiang was sentenced
to eight years in prison; Zhu Yufu, to seven years; and Xu Guang, to five
years.
News reports in December 2000 indicated that Wu had been held in solitary
confinement for the past seven months at No. 4 prison in eastern China's
Zhejiang Province, ever since protesting prison conditions in May.
An Jun, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: July 1999
Arrested in July 1999, An, an anticorruption campaigner, was sentenced
to four years in prison on subversion charges. The Intermediate People's
Court in Xinyang, Henan Province, announced the verdict on April 19, 2000,
citing An's essays and articles on corruption as evidence of his anti-state
activities.
A former manager of an export trading company, An founded the China Corruption
Monitor in 1998. The group reportedly exposed more than 100 cases of corruption.
During his November 1999 trial, An "said he was only trying to help the
government end rampant corruption," according to the news agency Agence
France-Presse.
Qi Yanchen, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: September 2, 1999
Police arrested Qi at his home in Cangzhou, in Hebei Province. His wife
told reporters that police had confiscated his computer, his printer,
his fax machine, and a number of documents.
Qi had published many articles in intellectual journals and was associated
with the online magazine Consultations, a publication linked to
the banned China Development Union (CDU). He also subscribed to the pro-democracy
electronic newsletter VIP Reference, which is published by political
dissidents based in the United States. Qi also worked as an economist
with the local Agricultural Development Bank of China.
Qi's arrest came after he posted online excerpts of his unpublished book
The Collapse of China. The book discussed various aspects of China's
social instability and suggested a number of possible reforms, according
to Richard Long, editor of VIP Reference. Long said Qi was arrested
for "spreading anti-government messages via the Internet."
On May 30, 2000, Qi was prosecuted for subversion before the Cangzhou
People's Court. The half-day trial was closed to the public. On September
19, he was sentenced to four years in prison.
Zhang Ji, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: October, 1999
Zhang Ji, a student at Qiqihar University in the northeastern province
of Heilongjiang, was charged on November 8, 1999, with "disseminating
reactionary documents via the Internet," according to the Hong Kongbased
Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy.
Zhang had allegedly been distributing news and information about the banned
spiritual movement Falun Gong. He was arrested sometime in October as
part of the Chinese government's crackdown on the sect.
Using the Internet, Zhang reportedly transmitted news of the crackdown
to Falun Gong members in the United States and Canada and also received
reports from abroad, which he then circulated among practitioners in China.
Before Zhang's arrest, Chinese authorities had been stepping up their
surveillance of the Internet as part of their effort to crush Falun Gong.
Huang Qi, Tianwang Web site
IMPRISONED: June 3, 2000
Huang, owner of the dissident Web site Tianwang (www.6-4tianwang.com),
was imprisoned in Chengdu, Sichuan Province, along with his wife, Zeng
Li. The arrest happened one day before the 11th anniversary of the Tiananmen
Square massacre.
At 5:00 p.m., four officers from the local Public Security Bureau (PSB)
visited Huang's office to deliver an oral summons for his interrogation.
They left after Huang requested a written summons, according to his own
account, which he immediately posted on his Web site. Huang continued
to post updates until 5:20 p.m., when around a dozen PSB officers arrived
at the office. They raided the premises, confiscating notebooks, photographs,
and computers. Both Huang and his wife Zeng were taken into custody. Just
before the raid, Huang posted a final bulletin to the site:
"Thanks to everybody devoted to democracy in China. They are here now
(the policemen). So long."
Zeng was released on June 6. Later that day, PSB officers informed her
that Huang was being charged with subversion, according to the Hong Kongbased
Information Centre for Human Rights and Democracy.
The Tianwang Web site was established in June 1999 to publicize information
about missing persons in China. Gradually, it also began to feature commentary
and news articles on topics not normally covered by the state-controlled
media. The site published stories about human-rights abuses, government
corruption, and—just days before Huang was taken into custody—several
pieces about the Tiananmen Square massacre.
After Huang's arrest, a message posted on Tianwang condemned the "political
persecution" of Huang Qi, and noted that authorities had shut down the
Web site at the end of February because it "posted a lot of internal news
that upset the leaders."
COMOROS: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Col. Azali Assoumani
Mission of the Federal and Islamic
Republic of the Comoros to the United Nations
New York, NY 10022
Fax: 212-983-4712
Cheick Ali Cassim, Tropik FM,
IMPRISONED: August 15, 2000
Cheick Ali Cassim, director of the private Tropik FM, was in government
(military) custody for "undermining state security through the illegal
[possession] of firearms." His house was searched, but no weapons were
found. Cassim is also a local political leader, and his private radio
station Tropik FM is a relentless critic of the Comoros' military government.
CUBA: 3
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Fidel Castro Ruz
President of Cuba
c/o Cuban Mission to the United Nations
315 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10016
Fax: 212-779-1679
Bernardo Rogelio Arévalo Padrón, Línea Sur Press
IMPRISONED: November 18, 1997
Arévalo Padrón, founder of the Línea Sur Press news
agency in the province of Cienfuegos, remains jailed despite being eligible
for parole, and his health has suffered as a result of his prolonged imprisonment.
Since April 6, 2000, the journalist has been held in the overcrowded and
unsanitary San Marcos labor camp, in the municipality of Lajas, Cienfuegos,
where he works cutting weeds with a machete in sugar cane fields. He is
being fed an extremely poor diet of rice and watered-down broth. According
to the independent news agency CubaPress, prison authorities keep a constant
watch on Arévalo Padrón, censor his incoming and outgoing
mail, and threaten to send him to a maximum-security prison if he does
not meet his production quota.
On October 31, 1997, the Provincial Chamber of the Court of Aguada de
Pasajeros, a town in Cienfuegos, sentenced Arévalo Padrón
to six years imprisonment for showing "lack of respect" for President
Fidel Castro Ruz and for Cuban State Council member Carlos Lage. The charges
stemmed from a series of interviews Arévalo Padrón gave
in late 1997 to Miami-based radio stations. In the interviews, the journalist
alleged that, while Cuban farmers went hungry, helicopters were being
used to transport fresh meat from the countryside to the dinner tables
of Castro, Lage, and other Communist Party officials in Havana.
On November 18, 1997, state security officers detained Arévalo
Padrón and sent him to jail. The journalist served the early part
of his sentence in maximum-security Ariza prison in Cienfuegos, where
he shared a filthy cell with criminals. On April 11, 1998, state security
officers beat up Arévalo Padrón after accusing him of writing
anti-government posters in prison. He was subsequently placed in solitary
confinement. Later, another prisoner was identified as having written
the posters.
While at Ariza, Arévalo Padrón faced constant harassment,
according to local colleagues. Fellow inmates who managed to make contact
with him were transferred or subjected to reprisals. In addition, Arévalo
Padrón suffered bouts of bronchitis and was reportedly treated
twice for high blood pressure in the prison infirmary. On January 8, 2000,
the journalist was transferred to labor camp No. 20, in the municipality
of Abréu, Cienfuegos, where he served four months.
Because of the strenuous work at several labor camps, Arévalo Padrón
has developed lower back pain (sacrolumbagia) and coronary blockage. After
ignoring Arévalo Padrón's pain for weeks, in September prison
authorities allowed him to undergo a medical examination, CubaPress reported.
A doctor determined that Arévalo Padrón's health conditions
make him unable to do physical work and that he should permanently wear
an orthopedic bandage. Prison authorities have neglected to provide Arévalo
Padrón with the orthopedic bandage, claiming that they lack fuel
or transportation to take Arévalo Padrón to a shop where
bandages are made, in order to take his measurements.
In mid-October, prison authorities informed Arévalo Padrón
that his release on parole had been approved. However, when Libertad Acosta,
Arévalo Padrón's wife, hired a lawyer to press for his release,
the lawyer told her that the Aguada de Pasajeros court had not met to
discuss Arévalo Padrón's case and had not requested that
prison authorities send a report on his behavior. In violation of Cuban
law, Arévalo Padrón remains held in the San Marcos labor
camp.
On July 25, 2000, CPJ wrote a protest letter urging President Fidel Castro
to ensure that imprisoned journalists Manuel Antonio González Castellanos,
Jesús Joel Díaz Hernández, and Arévalo Padrón
be immediately released from prison, and that their unjust convictions
be reversed.
Jesús Joel Díaz Hernández, Cooperativa Avileña
de Periodistas Independientes, IMPRISONED: January 18, 1999
Díaz Hernández, executive director of the independent news
service Cooperativa Avileña de Periodistas Independientes (CAPI),
was imprisoned during all of 2000 at the Canaleta prison, but was released
on January 17, 2001.
On January 18, 1999, the journalist was arrested at his home in the town
of Morón, in the central province of Ciego de Ávila, by
officers of the Revolutionary National Police (PNR). The next day he was
convicted of "dangerousness" and sentenced to four years in prison by
the Morón Municipal Court. Díaz Hernández subsequently
started a hunger strike and refused to drink water after his detention
to appeal the conviction.
After a summary session on January 22, 1999, the Provincial Court in Ciego
de Ávila confirmed Díaz Hernández's sentence even
though he was not permitted to have his attorney present (he was represented
by a state-appointed lawyer). He ended his hunger strike on January 28
and began drinking liquids.
In July of the same year, Díaz Hernández started another
hunger strike, this one lasting 17 days. In September, after spending
eight months in solitary confinement, the journalist was transferred to
a section of the prison where other inmates convicted of "dangerousness"
were held.
CPJ's local sources reported that on November 11, 1999, just before the
Ninth Ibero-American Summit held in Havana, Díaz Hernández
went on a third hunger strike to call for a general amnesty for political
prisoners in Cuba. He was again placed in solitary confinement, even though
his sentence calls for correctional work in a labor camp.
On November 23, 1999, CPJ honored Díaz Hernández with an
International Press Freedom Award. Guests at the awards ceremony in New
York City signed 312 postcards urging President Fidel Castro Ruz to release
the journalist immediately. The postcards were delivered via Federal Express
to the Cuba Interests Section in Washington D.C. on February 4, 2000.
In July 2000, Díaz Hernández's colleagues reported that
the journalist was suffering from hepatitis and was not receiving proper
medical treatment. Díaz Hernández's condition was diagnosed
only after his family took a urine sample without the prison guards' knowledge.
The same month, prison guards took Díaz Hernández's books
away from him, and forbade his relatives to bring any books to the journalist.
Last October, Díaz Hernández was placed in a cell with nine
other inmates convicted of "dangerousness," according to CAPI. Because
his family gave him medicines and vitamins, he appeared to have recovered
from hepatitis. Although Díaz Hernández was allowed to have
books again in his cell, prison guards at Canaleta continued to withhold
some of his books and letters that they had confiscated in July.
On January 17, 2001, without explanation, prison authorities summoned
the journalist's parents to Canaleta prison. Once they arrived, Díaz
Hernández was released, bearing a document stating that his sentence
had been suspended. Having served two years, Díaz Hernández
was at the midpoint of his sentence.
Manuel Antonio González Castellanos, CubaPress
IMPRISONED: October 1, 1998
González Castellanos, the imprisoned correspondent for the independent
news agency CubaPress in the eastern province of Holguín, has been
denied medical assistance and legal benefits.
In mid-November 2000, González Castellanos, who is eligible for
parole but has been denied this benefit, was told to gather his personal
belongings, because he was one of 60 prisoners to be transferred to a
labor camp, where conditions would be less harsh. When the day of the
transfer arrived, González Castellanos was called and told that
he would stay at the Holguín Provisional Prison. To protest this
arbitrary treatment, the journalist refused to accept the two-month sentence
reduction that prison authorities had granted him.
In a prison visit on November 18, 2000, González Castellanos's
"reeducation" officer told the journalist's relatives that only the state
security agency had jurisdiction in his case.
The journalist was arrested on October 1, 1998, for making critical statements
about President Fidel Castro Ruz to state security agents who had stopped
and insulted him as he was walking home from a friend's house. González
Castellanos was detained in the Holguín Provisional Prison, where
he spent seven months awaiting trial. On May 6, 1999, the San Germán
Municipal Court convicted him of "disrespect" and sentenced him to two
years and seven months' imprisonment.
While the sedition charges against González Castellanos did not
arise directly from his journalistic work, local journalists suspect that
González Castellanos was deliberately provoked by state security
agents in retaliation for his reporting on the activities of political
dissidents.
In July 1998, González Castellanos was contacted by a man claiming
to have information for him sent by a Cuban exile in Miami. When they
met, this man questioned González Castellanos about his journalistic
work and told him that a Cuban exile group wanted to recruit him for subversive
activities. González Castellanos declined the offer and later determined
that the man with whom he had met had never been in touch with the Miami
exiles that he claimed to represent. González Castellanos believed
the man was a state security agent attempting to entrap him.
On June 30, 1999, González Castellanos was transferred to Holguín's
maximum-security prison, Cuba Sí, where he was routinely harassed
by guards. When he complained about poor hygienic conditions, the guards
threatened to suspend his visiting rights. In late 1999, local independent
journalists reported that state security officers had promised to grant
other inmates special privileges if they would harass González
Castellanos and pass on information about the journalist.
On March 3, 2000, González Castellanos was transferred back to
Holguín Provisional Prison. On June 26, he was confined in a punishment
cell for 10 days, after being assaulted and punched in the head by the
prison's "reeducation" officer and a guard for protesting against the
confiscation of his handwritten notes.
Upon release from the punishment cell, González Castellanos was
placed in a labor unit. He had a severe cold for two months and lost considerable
weight, but was denied proper medical attention. The journalist's condition
improved only after his family managed to provide him with medication.
DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO: 4
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Joseph Kabila
President of the Democratic Republic of Congo
Ngaliema, Kinshasa
Democratic Republic of Congo
Fax: 011-234-88-02120/1-202-234-2609
Freddy Loseke Lisumbu La Yayenga, La Libre Afrique
IMPRISONED: December 31, 1999
Loseke, editor of the independent weekly La Libre Afrique, was
arrested at his Kinshasa home and held in solitary confinement at the
Kokolo military base. He was stripped of all his clothes, flogged, and
left to spend the night in a dingy, windowless cell.
Loseke's arrest resulted from two articles that he published in the December
29 and December 31, 1999 issues of La Libre Afrique, which has
since ceased publication. Both reports alleged an imminent army-sponsored
plot to overthrow President Kabila.
Loseke was initially charged with "betrayal of the state in times of war,"
a crime punishable by death.
Loseke's trial opened on January 11, 2000, at the Court of Military Order
(COM) in Kinshasa. Despite the DRC's constitutional due process guarantees,
he was denied legal representation. During the hearing, he was forced
to reveal confidential sources. He identified General Hilaire Muland Kapend
as the chief conspirator, outlined the coup plot, and named the plotters'
meeting spot. As a result of Loseke's forced testimony, police arrested
several suspects, including General Kapend (who was later released, according
to international news reports).
On April 14, a physically exhausted Loseke once again appeared before
the COM, this time with legal representation. In their closing argument,
Loseke's lawyers pleaded for his temporary release from detention on health
grounds (Loseke suffers from kidney failure, sources in Kinshasa reported).
The presiding military judge quickly dismissed the motion, however.
Without any explanation, and over the objections of Loseke's lawyers,
the charge was later changed to "insulting the army." Without further
deliberation, the journalist was found guilty of this second charge on
May 19, 2000, and sentenced to three years in prison. (COM decisions cannot
be appealed.)
CPJ protested Loseke's detention in four separate letters to President
Kabila, sent on January 20, March 13, May 3, and June 26. Kabila ordered
Loseke's release from prison on January 4, 2001, after 369 days in detention.
According to the DRC press-freedom organization Journaliste en Danger,
this was one of several recent amnesties granted under Kabila's "policy
of national reconciliation."
Aime Kakese Vinalu, Le Carrousel
IMPRISONED: June 24, 2000
Jean-Pierre Ekanga Mukuna, La Tribune de la Nation
IMPRISONED: August 17, 2000
Police arrested Vinalu on June 24, 2000, in connection with two articles
that he wrote in the June 20 edition of Le Carrousel. One article
lamented the lack of cooperation among various DRC opposition movements
and charged that free speech was impossible in the DRC because "to dare
speak one's mind is a sure guarantee that one will be accused of endangering
state security." The other piece speculated on possible reasons behind
a recent public confrontation between President Kabila and Minister for
Mineral Resources Victor M'Poyo (who was subsequently removed from his
post).
On July 26, the military prosecutor told local reporters that Vinalu's
articles had had the effect of "demoralizing the Army," describing them
as "veiled calls to opposition leaders and sympathizers to rebel against
the powers that be." The military prosecutor further announced that Vinalu
would be tried in a court martial because his alleged offenses amounted
to "high treason," an offense punishable by death.
Mukuna was arrested on June 23, 2000, reportedly for refusing to reveal
Vinalu's home address. He was released on July 10, but then re-arrested
on August 17, when he appeared in court to testify on Vinalu's behalf.
He was also charged with high treason and jailed at Kinshasa's Penitentiary
and Reeducation Centre.
Both journalists were sentenced to two years in jail without parole
on September 12, 2000. They were released on January 4, 2001 by presidential
amnesty.
Pierre-Sosthene Kambidi, Le Phare
IMPRISONED: December 31, 2000
Kambidi, the Kinshasa daily Le Phare's permanent correspondent
in Tshikapa (West Kasaï Province), was arrested and remained in custody
of the local branch of the National Information Agency (ANR). The order
to arrest the journalist allegedly came from Tshikapa's administrator,
Kalemba Tshibuabua, according to the local press-freedom group Journaliste
en Danger (JED). Kalemba blames the journalist for his critical articles
in Le Phare and his alleged links with the opposition Union for
Democracy and Social Progress (UDPS). JED also quoted Kabimdi's family
members as saying that the journalist was arrested because of his "intention
to publish an article on the illegal nature of [the administrator's] appointment
to Tshikapa."
Kambidi was reportedly released on January 2, 2001.
EGYPT: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Hosni Mubarak
President of the Arab Republic of Egypt
c/o His Excellency Ambassador Nabil Fahmy
Embassy of the Arab Republic of Egypt
3521 International Court N.W.
Washington, DC 20008
Fax: 202-244-4319
Hussein al-Mataani, Sahebat al Gallala
IMPRISONED: May 1, 1999
Al-Mataani was arrested on a number of charges stemming from his attempts
to form an independent journalists' union to compete with the government-recognized
Journalists' Syndicate. Al-Mataani was charged with forming a syndicate
without approval, collecting money from members, and misrepresenting himself
as a journalist. On June 19, he was sentenced to serve three and a half
years in prison. It was unclear whether al-Mataani was also convicted
on the separate charge of publishing the union's weekly newspaper, Sahebat
al Gallala, without a license By the end of December 2000, CPJ was
unable to confirm if al-Mataani was still in prison.
ETHIOPIA: 7
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Meles Zenawi
Prime Minister of Ethiopia
Office of the Prime Minister
P.O. Box 1031
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Fax: 251-155-2030
Garuma Bekele, Solomon Nemera, and Tesfaye Deressa, Urji
IMPRISONED: October 16, 1997
Garuma, publisher of the weekly newspaper Urji, and the paper's
editor Deressa were arrested in Addis Ababa a few days after the publication
of a report on the killing by government forces of three alleged members
of the outlawed Oromo Liberation Front (OLF). The Urji article contradicted
the official version of the incident by stating that the three were indeed
of the Oromo ethnic group but were not involved with the OLF.
Three weeks later, police arrested Nemera, a journalist with Urji, who
had just been appointed the paper's editor to replace Deressa. It remains
unclear what motivated Nemera's arrest.
In October 1999, Garuma and Deressa were tried and sentenced to a year
in jail each for publishing "false information." Nemera also received
the same sentence in February 2000, presumably on the same charge. In
addition, the three men were charged with terrorist activities, along
with three dozen other members of the Oromo ethnic group, under Article
252 of Ethiopia's Penal Code. The Article provides that court hearings
in such cases be held in secrecy and that convicted terrorists are jailed
for at least 15 years. No bail is allowed.
Tamrat Gemeda, Seife Nebelbal
IMPRISONED: October 1997
Gemeda, a journalist with the private Amharic weekly Seife Nebelbal,
completed his initial jail term but must remain in detention, unable to
afford bail, while trials for numerous other charges are pending. He is
now being held on charges of involvement with a guerrilla organization,
the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF). Arrested in October 1997 for "inciting
the public to violence" in an article about the armed conflict between
the government and the OLF, Gemeda was sentenced to three years in jail
under various provisions of the Penal Code and Press Proclamation 34/1992.
In March 2000, he was given an additional one-year jail term for publishing
"false information" in connection with the same article. Court officials
on numerous occasions declined to accept bail from him on the grounds
that in 1997 he had gone into hiding when he was supposed to appear in
court. In fact, the journalist was being held in an Addis Ababa jail.
He has since then been trying to obtain confirmation of his detention
from the prison authorities.
Tewodros Kassa, Ethiop
IMPRISONED: June 2000
The Federal High Court convicted Kassa, editor of the private Amharic
weekly Ethiop, of disseminating false information that could incite
people to political violence, under Articles 10(1) and 20(21) of Press
Proclamation 34/1992 and Article 48(6) of the Penal Code. The charges
stemmed from an Ethiop article, whose contents remain unclear.
Some local sources have told CPJ that Kassa's article was about the murder
by poisoning of a commander of the Ethiopian Army by a female spy of the
armed separatist Oromo Liberation Front (OLF).
Kassa was given a choice between serving one year in prison or paying
a fine of 15,000 birr (US$1850), according to the Ethiopian Free Press
Journalists Association (EFJA).
On November 13, the jailed Kassa was called to court to face the new charge
of "defaming the good reputation of Duki Feyssa by disseminating false
information through the newspaper." According to the EFJA, this charge
resulted from an Ethiop article titled "Businessman Killed by Unidentified
Force," which speculated that local businessman Duki Feyssa, a suspected
OLF member, may have been killed by state security forces. When Kassa
finishes his current jail term, he will be forced to fight this new charge.
Bizunish Debebe, Zegabi
IMPRISONED: July 31, 2000
Debebe, editor in chief of the private Amharic weekly, Zegabi,
was sentenced to six months imprisonment for violating the Press Law by
publishing an article entitled, "OLF launches attack in Bale." CPJ was
unable to confirm the exact charge or other details in the case, but journalists
who covered the separatist Oromo Liberation Front (OLF) were often jailed
for "distribution of false news likely to incite violence" or "membership
in a terrorist organization."
Debebe, a veteran of Ethiopia's very small community of women journalists,
has been a regular target of the regime. Most recently, in August 1999,
she was charged with violating the press law by failing to publish the
name of her newspaper's deputy editor, and sentenced to a year behind
bars. She posted bail at the start of 2000 and was released on February
2. She was again arrested on July 31.
Melese Shine, Ethiop
IMPRISONED: November 2000
Shine, editor of the intermittently distributed private Amharic weekly
Ethiop, was charged with disseminating false information that endangers
national security, under Article 10/20/1 of Press Proclamation 34/1992
and Article 480(b) of the Penal Code.
The charge resulted from an article published in Ethiop in September
2000 entitled, "Eritrean Opposition Forces Being Trained in Areas of Rama
and Assayita." Shine's arrest seems to have been triggered by the claim
that Ethiopia was organizing Eritrean opposition forces as a retaliatory
measure.
The Federal High Court had recently reduced bail requirements for violations
of the Press Law. In Shine's case, however, the court demanded bail of
10,000 birr (US$1200), an exorbitant sum for an independent journalist
in Ethiopia. Meanwhile, the trial was postponed until October 2001.
With the help of international press-freedom groups, the Ethiopian Free
Press Journalists Association was able to raise enough money to pay Shine's
bail, and complete all other necessary formalities to secure the journalist's
release. On January 6, 2001, the Federal High Court ordered Shine's release;
he was freed the next day.
IRAN: 6
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Ayatollah Ali Khamenei
Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran
c/o The Permanent Mission of Iran to the United Nations
622 Third Avenue, 34th Floor
New York, NY 10017
Fax: 212-867-7086
Abdullah Nouri, Khordad
IMPRISONED: November 28, 1999
In a trial that gripped the nation, the Special Court for Clergy convicted
Nouri, publisher of the reformist daily Khordad and a former vice
president and interior minister, of religious dissent on November 27,
1999. The conviction was widely viewed as an attempt by conservative forces
within the regime to sideline Nouri, an influential ally of reformist
president Muhammad Khatami, in advance of the country's February 2000
election. Nouri was believed to be a frontrunner for the important position
of speaker of Iran's Majlis (Parliament).
The charges against him, which included defaming "the system," insulting
religious leaders, and disseminating false information and propaganda
against the state, were based on news articles published in Khordad.
During the trial, Nouri transfixed the nation with a poignant self-defense
in which he sharply criticized the clerical establishment and called for
more freedom in Iranian society.
He was sentenced to five years in prison and barred from practicing journalism
for five years. Khordad was ordered to close. At year's end, Nouri
was serving his sentence in Tehran's Evin Prison.
Akbar Ganji, Sobh-e-Emrooz, Fat'h
IMPRISONED: April 22, 2000
Ganji, a leading investigative reporter for the reformist daily Sobh-e-Emrooz
and a member of the editorial board of the pro-reform daily Fath,
was arrested because of his writings and for participating in a conference
about the Iranian reform movement that took place in Germany. He faced
prosecution in both the Press Court and the Revolutionary Court.
The Press Court case stemmed from Ganji's investigative articles about
the alleged involvement of senior intelligence officials and other regime
hardliners in the 1998 killings of several Iranian dissidents and intellectuals.
In the Revolutionary Court case, he was accused of propaganda against
the Islamic regime and threatening national security in comments at a
Berlin conference on the future of the Iranian reform movement.
During a dramatic court appearance on November 9, Ganji charged that he
had been hung upside down and beaten by guards at Tehran's Evin Prison,
where he was being held in solitary confinement.
Latif Safari, Neshat
IMPRISONED: April 23, 2000
Safari, director of the banned daily Neshat, which was closed by
court order in September, 1999, was imprisoned after an appellate court
upheld a 30-month jail sentence that the court had imposed on September
20, 1999. Safari was convicted on several charges, including defamation,
inciting unrest, and "insulting the sanctity and tenets of Islam." These
charges stemmed from articles published in Neshat during Safari's
tenure as director, including an opinion piece that challenged the use
of capital punishment in Iran.
He is serving his sentence in Tehran's Evin Prison.
Emadeddin Baghi, Fat'h, Neshat
IMPRISONED: May 29, 2000
Baghi, who had written for the banned daily Neshat and was a member
of the editorial board of another outlawed daily, Fat'h, was detained
during the middle of a closed-door trial on charges related to his work
as a journalist. On July 17, Tehran's Press Court sentenced him to five
and a half years in prison.
According to the Islamic Republic News Agency (IRNA), Baghi had been charged
with publishing articles that "questioned the validity of...Islamic law,"
with "threatening national security, and...for spreading unsubstantiated
news stories" about the role of "agents of the Intelligence Ministry in
the serial murder of intellectuals and dissidents in 1998." The charges
were based on complaints lodged by a number of government agencies, including
the Intelligence Ministry, the conservative controlled Islamic Republic
of Iran Broadcasting, and former security officials.
The charges also included mention of a 1999 piece Baghi published in Neshat
in response to another article criticizing the death penalty that had
itself landed Neshat editor Mashallah Shamsolvaezin in jail. The
closed-door trial began on May 1. In late October, an appeals court reduced
the sentence to three years. He remains in Tehran's Evin Prison.
Mashallah Shamsolvaezin, Asr-e-Azadegan, Neshat
IMPRISONED: April 10, 2000
An appellate court sentenced Shamsolvaezin, editor of the daily Asr-e-Azadegan,
to 30 months in prison for allegedly insulting Islamic principles in a
1999 article that criticized capital punishment in Iran. Shamsolvaezin
was taken to Tehran's Evin Prison shortly after the verdict.
The article was published in the now-defunct daily Neshat, which
Shamsolvaezin edited until judicial authorities closed the paper in September
1999. On November 27, 1999, a Tehran court sentenced Shamsolvaezin to
three years in prison. The appeals court reduced the sentence to 30 months
after acquitting him of allegedly forging the article, which was written
by a London-based activist, Hossein Baqerzadeh.
On November 23, 2000, CPJ honored Shamsolvaezin with an International
Press Freedom Award.
Ahmed Zeid-Abadi, Hamshahri
IMPRISONED: August 7, 2000
Zeid-Abadi, a journalist with the moderate daily Hamshahri, was
arrested by order of Tehran's Press Court. The court announced that Zeid-Abadi
had been arrested after ignoring a summons to appear before the court.
Police searched the journalist's home and confiscated books and other
materials. Zeid-Abadi was still imprisoned at year's end; the motive for
his arrest was unclear.
KUWAIT: 2
Please send appeals to:
His Highness Sheikh Jaber al-Ahmed al-Sabah
Emir of Kuwait
Al-Diwan al-Amiri
Al-Safat
Kuwait City, Kuwait
Fax: 965-243-0121
Ibtisam Berto Sulaiman al-Dakhil and Fawwaz Muhammad al-Awadi Bessisso,
Al-Nida'
IMPRISONED: June 1991
Along with three other journalists, Bessisso and al-Dakhil were sentenced
to life in prison for their work with Al-Nida', a newspaper launched
by Iraqi authorities during Iraq's occupation of Kuwait in 1990. As of
December 2000, they were the last remaining journalists in prison in Kuwait,
which jailed 17 reporters and editors following the Gulf War for their
work with Al-Nida'.
Kuwaiti authorities arrested Bessisso and al-Dakhil after the liberation
of Kuwait and charged them with collaboration. The defendants were reportedly
tortured during their interrogations. The trial, which began on May 19,
1991, in a martial-law court, failed to meet international standards of
justice. In particular, prosecutors did not rebut the journalists' defense
that they had been forced to work for the Iraqi newspaper.
On June 16, 1991, the journalists were sentenced to death. Ten days later,
following international protests, all martial-law death sentences were
commuted to life imprisonment. The 15 other journalists jailed for their
work with Al-Nida' were freed piecemeal starting in 1996, most
on the occasion of the emir's annual amnesty in February.
NEPAL: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Girija Prasad Koirala
Prime Minister, The Kingdom of Nepal
Office of the Prime Minister
Singh Durbar
Kathmandu, Nepal
Fax: 977-1-227-286
Krishna Sen, Janadesh
IMPRISONED: April 19, 1999
Police arrested Sen, editor of the Nepali-language weekly Janadesh,
and seized thousands of copies of the newspaper.
According to CPJ's sources, Sen was arrested in connection with a recent
issue of Janadesh that featured an interview with Baburam Bhattarai,
one of the leaders of Nepal's Maoist insurgency. Police reportedly confiscated
20,000 copies of the edition in order to prevent the interview from being
widely read.
While Janadesh is considered a pro-Maoist paper, journalists in
Nepal told CPJ that it is a vital source of information regarding the
guerrilla movement. The Federation of Nepalese Journalists protested Sen's
imprisonment.
Sen was still in custody at the end of December 2000, despite a Supreme
Court ruling in August 1999 that his arrest was illegal under the habeas
corpus guarantees of Nepal's constitution. According to Sen's lawyer,
police and district officials then conspired to keep Sen in detention
by forging release papers and re-arresting him on trumped-up charges.
Sen's next court appearance was scheduled for February 2001.
NIGER: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Mamadou Tandja
President of the Republic
Niamey, Niger
Fax: 227-72-2245
Soumaina Maiga, L'Enquêteur
IMPRISONED: November 16, 2000
On November 16, a Niamey court sentenced Maiga, publisher of the private
weekly L'Enquêteur, to eight months in prison and a fine of US$685.
The paper's managing editor Dahirou Gouro and a reporter, Salif Dago,
also received six-month suspended sentences and a fine of US$410 each.
The three journalists were convicted of "disturbing the public order"
and of "spreading false information." Niger's Defense Ministry filed a
complaint against L'Enquêteur after the weekly ran an article about
a protracted dispute between Benin and Niger concerning Tete Island, a
small landmass in the Niger River that both countries claim. L'Enquêteur
reported that Benin had deployed troops on Tete Island to evict residents
with Niger citizenship, and alleged that Benin was planning to cut diplomatic
relations with Niger. The three journalists were first arrested between
October 23 and 25 and were held for a week before they were released on
bail pending their trial. L'Enquêteur, meanwhile, has ceased publishing.
Maiga was released on January 19, 2001.
SYRIA: 1
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Bashar al-Assad
President of the Syrian Arab Republic
c/o His Excellency Ambassador Walid al-Moualem
Embassy of the Syrian Arab Republic
2215 Wyoming Avenue N.W.
Washington, DC 20008
United States
Fax: 202-234-9548
Nizar Nayyouf, Sawt al-Democratiyya
IMPRISONED: January 1992
Nayyouf, a former free-lance journalist, leading member of the independent
Committees for the Defense of Democratic Freedoms and Human Rights in
Syria (CDF), and editor of its monthly publication Sawt al-Democratiyya,
was arrested in January 1992 and later convicted by the Supreme State
Security Court of membership in an unauthorized organization and of disseminating
false information. He was severely tortured during his interrogation.
Nayyouf is serving a 10-year sentence and reportedly suffers from Hodgkin's
disease and several other serious ailments, including partial paralysis
of his lower extremities as a result of torture. He is also said to suffer
from kidney failure and deteriorating eyesight.
TUNISIA: 2
Please send appeals to:
M. Zine El Abidine Ben Ali
President of the Republic of Tunisia
Presidential Palace
Tunis, Tunisia
Fax: 216-1-744-721
Hamadi Jebali, Al-Fajr
IMPRISONED: January 1991
On August 28, 1992, the military court in Bouchoucha sentenced Jebali,
editor of Al-Fajr, the weekly newspaper of the banned Islamist
Al-Nahda Party, to 16 years in prison. He was tried along with 279 other
individuals accused of membership in Al-Nahda. Jebali was convicted of
"aggression with the intention of changing the nature of the state" and
"membership in an illegal organization."
During his testimony, Jebali denied the charges against him and displayed
evidence that he had been tortured while in custody. Jebali has been in
jail since January 1991, when he was sentenced to one year in prison after
Al-Fajr published an article calling for the abolition of military
courts in Tunisia. International human-rights groups monitoring the mass
trial concluded that the proceedings fell far below international standards
of justice.
Abdellah Zouari, Al-Fajr
IMPRISONED: February 1991
On August 28, 1992, the military court in Bouchoucha sentenced Zouari,
a contributor to Al-Fajr, the weekly newspaper of the banned Islamist
Al-Nahda Party, to 11 years in prison. Zouari was tried along with 279
other individuals accused of belonging to Al-Nahda.
He has been in jail since February 1991, when he was charged with "association
with an unrecognized organization." International human-rights groups
monitoring the trial concluded it fell far short of meeting international
standards of justice.
TURKEY: 14
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Bulent Ecevit
Prime Minister of the Republic of Turkey
c/o His Excellency Baki Ilkin
Embassy of the Republic of Turkey
2525 Massachusetts Avenue N.W.
Washington, DC 20008
Fax: 202-612-6744
Sinan Yavuz, Yoksul Halkin Gucu
IMPRISONED: August 9, 1993
Yavuz, editor of the left-wing weekly Yoksul Halkin Gucu, was arrested
during a police raid on an Istanbul fabric shop. Police reportedly had
been told that the shop served as a front and arms-trafficking station
for Devrimci Sol (also known as Dev Sol), an outlawed leftist organization
responsible for numerous armed terrorist operations in Turkey. The charges
against Yavuz show that he was alleged to be a member of Dev Sol, apparently
on the basis of his affiliation with Yoksul Halkin Gucu, which
the government asserts is Dev Sol's publishing arm. The evidence against
Yavuz consisted of unspecified "documents" relating to Dev Sol and two
copies of the far-left magazine Kurtulus, which were allegedly
discovered during a search of the fabric shop. Yavuz was alleged to have
resisted arrest after attempting to flee during the raid.
Yavuz had been detained on previous occasions but released for lack of
evidence. He confessed to nothing in police custody, but the prosecution
claimed that other members of Dev Sol who were detained in the same roundup
stated that Yavuz was a member of their group. According to court documents,
Yavuz waved a Dev Sol banner in the courtroom during his trial, an act
that led to his conviction. On December 29, 1994, he was sentenced to
12 years and six months in jail and sent to Canakkale Prison. He is currently
in a prison in Sincan, a district just outside Ankara.
Huseyin Solak, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: October 27, 1993
Solak, the Gaziantep bureau chief of the socialist magazine Mucadele,
was arrested and charged under Article 168 of the Penal Code with membership
in Devrimci Sol (also known as Dev Sol), an outlawed underground leftist
organization responsible for numerous terrorist operations in Turkey.
Solak was convicted on the strength of statements from a witness who said
he had seen the journalist distributing copies of Mucadele.
According to the transcript of Solak's trial, the prosecution witness
also testified that Solak had hung unspecified banners in public and served
as a lookout while members of Dev Sol threw a Molotov cocktail at a bank
in the town of Gaziantep. The prosecution also cited "illegal" documents
found after searches of Solak's home and office. Solak confessed to the
charges while in police custody but recanted in court.
On November 24, 1994, Solak was sentenced to serve 12 years and six months
in prison. As of December 2000 he was being held in a prison in the town
of Cankiri.
Hasan Ozgun, Ozgur Gundem
IMPRISONED: December 9, 1993
Ozgun, a Diyarbakir correspondent for the now-defunct pro-Kurdish daily
Ozgur Gundem, was arrested during a December 9, 1993, police raid
on the paper's Diyarbakir bureau. He was charged with being a member of
the outlawed Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), under Article 168 of the
Penal Code.
Transcripts of Ozgun's trial show that the prosecution based its case
on what it described as Ozgur Gundem's pro-PKK slant, following
a Turkish-government pattern of harassing journalists affiliated with
the publication. The prosecution also submitted copies of the banned PKK
publications Serkhabun and Berxehun, found in Ozgun's possession,
as well as photographs and biographical sketches of PKK members from the
newspaper's archive. The state also cited Ozgun's possession of an unauthorized
handgun as evidence of his membership in the PKK.
In his defense, Ozgun maintained that the PKK publications were used as
sources of information for newspaper articles and that the photos of PKK
members were in the archive because of interviews the newspaper had conducted
in the past. Ozgun admitted to having purchased the gun on the black market
but denied all other charges.
As of December 2000, Ozgun was believed to be in Aydin Prison.
Serdar Gelir, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: April 25, 1994
Gelir, Ankara bureau chief for the weekly socialist magazine Mucadele,
was detained on April 16, 1994. He was formally arrested and imprisoned
10 days later, on the charge of membership in an illegal organization.
The Ministry of Justice informed CPJ that Gelir was charged and convicted
under Article 168 of the Penal Code and Article 5 of the Anti-Terror Law
3713 and sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment by the Ankara State Security
court for being a member of an armed, illegal leftist organization (Devrimci
Sol, also known as Dev Sol). Court records, however, indicate that he
was sentenced to 12 years and six months. As of December 2000, Gelir was
being held in a prison in the town of Sincan, outside Ankara.
Utku Deniz Sirkeci, Tavir
IMPRISONED: August 6, 1994
Sirkeci, the Ankara bureau chief of the leftist cultural magazine Tavir,
was arrested and charged with membership in the outlawed organization
Devrimci Sol (also known as Dev Sol), under Article 168 of the Penal Code.
Court records from Sirkeci's trial show that the state accused him of
throwing a Molotov cocktail at a bank in Ankara, but the documents do
not state what evidence was introduced to support the allegation. Prosecutors
also cited Sirkeci's attendance at the funeral of a Dev Sol activist to
support the charge that he was a member of the organization.
In his defense, Sirkeci said he had attended the funeral in his capacity
as a journalist. He provided detailed testimony of his torture at the
hands of police, who, he alleged, coerced him to confess.
He was convicted and sentenced to 12 years and six months in prison. At
year's end, he was being held in a prison in the town of Sincan, outside
Ankara.
Aysel Bolucek, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: October 11, 1994
Bolucek, an Ankara correspondent for the weekly socialist magazine Mucadele,
was arrested at her home and charged with membership in an outlawed organization
under Article 168 of the Penal Code, partly on the basis of a handwritten
document that allegedly linked her to the banned leftist group Devrimci
Sol (also known as Dev Sol). She has been in prison since her arrest.
Court documents from her trial show that the state also cited the October
8, 1994, issue of Mucadele to support its argument that the magazine
was a Dev Sol publication. The prosecutor claimed that the October 8 issue
contained material that insulted security forces and state officials and
praised Dev Sol guerrillas who had been killed in clashes with security
forces.
The defense argued that it was illegal for the defendant to be tried twice
for the same crime. (Earlier in 1994, Bolucek had been acquitted on a
charge of membership in Dev Sol for which the primary evidence was the
same handwritten document.) The defense accepted the prosecution's claim
that Bolucek had written the document but said that the police forced
her to write it under torture while she was in custody.
The defense also argued that a legal publication could not be used as
evidence and that the individuals who made incriminating statements about
Bolucek to the police had done so under torture and subsequently recanted.
But on December 23, 1994, Bolucek was convicted of membership in an outlawed
organization and sentenced to 12 years and six months in jail.
As of December 2000, she was being held in Kutahya Prison.
Ozlem Turk, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: January 17, 1995
Turk, a reporter in the town of Samsun for the weekly socialist magazine
Mucadele, was arrested at a relative's home and charged with membership
in the outlawed Revolutionary People's Liberation Party-Front, under Article
169 of the Penal Code. Court documents from her trial state that the prosecution's
evidence included the fact that Turk collected money for Mucadele,
along with a handwritten autobiography allegedly found in the home of
a member of the Revolutionary People's Liberation Party-Front. Two people
testified that she was a member of the group.
Turk maintained that the money she had collected came from sales of copies
of Mucadele. Turk also claimed that she was forced to confess to
the charges under torture. The only material evidence presented at the
trial was copies of legal publications—Mucadele, Tavir,
and Devrimci Genclik—found at her home and copies of her alleged
autobiography. Police provided expert testimony to authenticate the incriminating
documents.
According to court documents, Turk was convicted under Article 168 of
the Penal Code and sentenced to 15 years in prison. As of December 2000
she was being held in Kutahya Prison.
Burhan Gardas, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: March 23, 1995
Gardas, the Ankara bureau chief for the weekly socialist magazine Mucadele,
has been the target of several prosecutions since 1994, all related to
his work as a journalist. Court records state that Gardas was arrested
on January 12, 1994, at his office and charged with violating Article
168 of the Penal Code.
During a search of the premises, the police reportedly found four copies
of "news bulletins" of the outlawed organization Devrimci Sol (also known
as Dev Sol). In the course of the trial, the prosecution claimed that
police also found banners with left-wing slogans, along with photographs
of Dev Sol militants who had been killed in clashes with security forces.
The prosecution also claimed that Gardas shouted anti-state slogans during
his arrest and that he was using Mucadele's office for Dev Sol
activities.
Gardas denied all charges. His attorney argued that the illegal publications
were part of the magazine's archive and that Gardas had been tortured
in prison. (The lawyer submitted a medical report to document the alleged
torture.) On May 14, 1994, Gardas was released pending the outcome of
his trial.
While awaiting the verdict in the 1994 prosecution, Gardas was arrested
on March 23, 1995, when police raided the office of the weekly socialist
magazine Kurtulus, the successor to Mucadele, where he was
also the Ankara bureau chief. The new charge was that he had violated
Article 168 of the Penal Code, again relating to his alleged membership
in the banned organization Dev Sol. During the raid, police seized three
copies of Kurtulus "news bulletins" and six Kurtulus articles
in which illegal rallies were discussed.
Court documents from his second trial, which was held at the No. 2 State
Security Court of Ankara, reveal that the prosecution's evidence against
Gardas consisted of his refusal to talk during a police interrogation—allegedly
part of a Dev Sol policy—and his possession of publications that the prosecution
contended were the mouthpieces of outlawed organizations, including Mucadele
and Kurtulus. The state also introduced the testimony of Ali Han,
an employee at Kurtulus' Ankara bureau, that Gardas was a Dev Sol
member. Gardas denied the claim, and his lawyer argued that his silence
during police interrogation was a constitutional right and proved nothing.
On July 4, 1995, the No. 1 State Security Court of Ankara sentenced Gardas
to 15 years in prison on the 1994 charge. In 1996, he was convicted and
sentenced to an additional 15 years on the second set of charges. He has
thus been convicted twice of membership in Dev Sol, each time because
of his work as a journalist. As of December 2000, Gardas was serving his
term at a prison in Sincan, a district just outside of Ankara.
Ozgur Gudenoglu, Mucadele
IMPRISONED: May 24, 1995
Gudenoglu, Konya bureau chief of the socialist weekly magazine Mucadele,
was arrested, charged, tried, and convicted under Article 168 of the Penal
Code (belonging to an illegal organization). He was sentenced to 12 years
and six months in prison for alleged membership in the outlawed leftist
organization Devrimci Sol (also known as Dev Sol). His prosecution is
part of the state's long-standing pattern of harassment of Mucadele
and its employees.
Gudenoglu was reportedly confined in Nigde Prison at year's end.
Bulent Oner, Atilim
IMPRISONED: June 15, 1995
Oner, a reporter for the now-defunct weekly socialist newspaper Atilim,
was taken into custody during a June 15, 1995, police raid on the newspaper's
Mersin bureau. On June 24, according to court documents, he was charged
with membership in the outlawed Marxist-Leninist Communist Party (MLKP)
under Article 168 of the Penal Code.
Investigators reportedly found numerous unspecified "documents" linking
Oner to the MLKP. At his trial, two witnesses testified for the state,
which asserted that Atilim was published by the MLKP and further
accused Oner of writing and distributing unspecified MKLP "declarations."
According to the court documents, the prosecutor also claimed that banners
depicting a "disappeared" political activist had been found in Oner's
office.
Oner was convicted, sentenced to 12 years and six months in jail, and
sent to Erzurum Prison. As of December 2000, it was unclear where he was
being held.
Fatma Harman, Atilim
IMPRISONED: July 10, 1995
Harman, a reporter for the now-defunct weekly socialist newspaper Atilim,
was taken into custody during a June 15, 1995, police raid on the newspaper's
Mersin bureau. Her colleague Bulent Oner was also detained.
On June 24, 1995, Harman was formally arrested and charged under Article
168 of the Penal Code for her alleged membership in the outlawed Marxist-Leninist
Communist Party (MLKP). Atilim's lawyer reports that the prosecution
based its case on the argument that Atilim was published by the
MKLP. The prosecution introduced copies of Atilim found in Harman's
possession as evidence of her affiliation with the MLKP and claimed that
several unspecified "banners" were found in the Atilim office.
The prosecution also alleged that Harman and Oner both lived in a house
belonging to the MLKP. On January 26, 1996, Harman was sentenced to 12
years and six months in prison and confined to Adana Prison.
Erdal Dogan, Alinteri
IMPRISONED: July 10, 1995
Dogan, an Ankara reporter for the now-defunct socialist weekly Alinteri,
was arrested on July 10, 1995. He was charged under Article 168 of the
Penal Code for his alleged membership in the outlawed Turkish Revolutionary
Communist Union (TIKB).
According to the court transcript from Dogan's trial, the prosecution
argued that Alinteri was published by the TIKB. The case against
Dogan was based on the following evidence: (1) a photograph of Dogan,
taken at a 1992 May Day parade, allegedly showing him standing underneath
a United Revolutionary Trade Union banner; (2) a photograph of Dogan taken
on the anniversary of a TIKB militant's death; (3) a photograph alleged
to show Dogan attending an illegal demonstration in Ankara; (4) a statement
of an alleged member of the TIKB, who claimed that Dogan belonged to the
organization.
The defense argued that the allegedly incriminating statement was invalid,
because it had been extracted under torture. Dogan's lawyer told CPJ that
the photograph from the militant's memorial was blurry, and Dogan testified
in court that he had attended the May Day parade as a journalist. He was
convicted, sentenced to 12 years and six months in prison, and confined
to Bursa Prison. As of December 2000 he was being held in a prison in
the town of Sincan, outside Ankara.
Sadik Celik, Kurtulus
IMPRISONED: December 23, 1995
Although Celik, Zonguldak bureau chief for the leftist weekly Kurtulus,
was detained and charged with violating Article 168 of the Penal Code
for alleged membership in the outlawed Revolutionary People's Liberation
Party-Front (DHKP-C), the state's case rested almost exclusively on his
work as a journalist.
The prosecution claimed that Kurtulus was the publication of the
DHKP-C and that Celik's position with the magazine proved he was a member
of the group. Celik was accused of conducting "seminars" for the DHKP-C
at the magazine's office, propagandizing for the organization, transporting
copies of the magazine from Istanbul to Zonguldak by bus, and organizing
the magazine's distribution in Zonguldak. The prosecution also stated
that Celik's name appeared in a document written by a leader of the DHKP-C
(it is not clear whether the document was introduced as material evidence).
The prosecution claimed that Celik's refusal to testify in police custody
proved his guilt. The defense argued that the prosecution could not substantiate
any of its claims. Celik acknowledged having distributed the magazine
in his capacity as Kurtulus' bureau chief. He said that he held
meetings in the office to discuss the magazine's affairs. The defense
presented the statements of two Kurtulus reporters to corroborate
Celik's statements.
On October 17, 1996, Celik was sentenced to 12 years and six months in
prison. As of December 2000 he was being held in Edirne Prison.
Nabi Kimran, Iscinin Yolu
IMPRISONED: September 9, 1996
Kimran was editor of the leftist weekly Iscinin Yolu, which was
subject to repeated government harassment during his tenure.
According to court documents, police apprehended Kimran on a bus during
a police operation in advance of the anniversary of the outlawed Marxist-Leninist
Communist Party (MLKP). He was charged under Article 168 of the Penal
Code for his alleged membership in the MLKP. During his trial, the prosecution
charged that Kimran was a leader of the MLKP. The charge was based on
the statement of an alleged MLKP sympathizer, who said that Kimran had
ordered the bombing of a city bus. Kimran was also caught with a counterfeit
I.D., which he claimed to carry because of his fear of being detained
in the course of his journalistic work.
The prosecution stated that police who searched Kimran's apartment found
documents in his handwriting that demonstrated his affiliation with the
MLKP.
Kimran's lawyer told CPJ that the journalist was also charged under articles
7 (engaging in propaganda for an outlawed organization) and 8 (disseminating
separatist propaganda) of the Anti-Terror Law.
Staffers from the socialist weekly Atilim said these charges were
based on news articles that appeared in Iscinin Yolu during Kimran's
tenure. The Penal Code case was prosecuted, but the Anti-Terror Law cases
were eventually suspended following the government's so-called amnesty
for jailed editors, on August 14, 1997.
As of December 2000, Kimran was being held in Kandira Prison.
UZBEKISTAN: 3
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Islam Karimov
President of the Republic of Uzbekistan
43 Uzbekistanskaya Street
Tashkent, Uzbekistan 700163
Fax 998-71-139-55-25 or 988-71-139-5510
Shodi Mardiev, Samarkand Radio
IMPRISONED: November 15, 1997
Shodi Mardiev, a reporter with the state-run Samarkand radio station,
was in failing health as he served an 11-year prison term for defamation
and extortion.
Mardiev was originally sentenced on June 11, 1998. Though his sentence
was later cut in half under President Islam Karimov's decrees of April
30, 1999, and August 28, 2000, Mardiev still has approximately three years
left to serve. Given his age (60-plus) and increasingly poor health, he
may die in prison if he is forced to serve his remaining sentence.
Mardiev is being held in Penal Colony 64/47 in the town of Kizil-tepa
in the Navoi region. Local human-rights groups say many political prisoners
are sent to this particular correctional facility. Prisoners are allowed
only one visit every three months, and may receive only one package every
four months from outside the prison. The prison is also notorious for
its poor-quality medical facilities and food services.
Mardiev's physical and mental health have suffered as a result of these
poor conditions. Shortly after his arrest in November 1997, the journalist
suffered two cerebral hemorrhages while in a pre-trial detention center.
He was hospitalized twice last year for a heart condition, and is not
receiving proper medical attention.
Mardiev is known for his criticism of government officials and for his
satirical writings in the journal Mushtum. His imprisonment stemmed
from charges by Samarkand deputy prosecutor Talat Abdulkhalikzada that
Mardiev had defamed him in a June 19, 1997, broadcast that the journalist
produced for state radio in Samarkand. Abdulkhalikzada also alleged that
Mardiev had used the threat of the impending broadcast in an attempt to
extort money from him, although he provided the court with little evidence
to support this allegation.
On January 12 and November 20, 2000, CPJ wrote to President Karimov, urging
that Mardiev be released on humanitarian grounds and that the charges
against him be dropped.
Muhammad Bekjanov and Iusuf Ruzimuradov, Erk
IMPRISONED: March 15, 1999
Muhammad Bekjanov and Iusuf Ruzimuradov had been involved in the production
and distribution of the opposition newspaper Erk and were imprisoned
for 14 years and 15 years, respectively, at trial in Tashkent in August
1999. They were convicted on charges of distributing a banned newspaper
containing slanderous criticism of President Islam Karimov, participating
in a banned political protest, and attempting to overthrow the regime.
In addition, the court found them guilty of illegally leaving the country
and damaging their Uzbek passports.
The condition of Bekjanov and Ruzimuradov's pre-trail detention and the
prison camp in which they are being held are shocking. Both men were tortured
during their six-month pre-trial detention in the Tashkent city prison.
Today they are suffering appalling conditions in "strict regime" penal
colonies and their health is deteriorating.
According to human-rights activists in Tashkent, Bekjanov was transferred
on November 27 to ‘strict-regime' Penal Colony 64/46 in the city of Navoi
in central Uzbekistan. His health is reportedly poor and he has been suffering
from dysentery. He has lost considerable weight, and like many prisoners
in Uzbek camps is suffering from malnutrition. Local sources have informed
CPJ that Ruzimuradov is being held in strict regime Penal Colony 64/33
in the village of Shakhali near the town of Karshi.
VIETNAM: 2
Please send appeals to:
His Excellency Tran Duc Luong, President,
Socialist Republic of Vietnam
Hanoi, Socialist Republic of Vietnam
Fax: 844-823-1872
Nguyen Thanh Giang, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: March 4, 1999
Giang, a prominent writer and geophysicist, was arrested by police in
Hanoi for allegedly possessing "anti-socialist propaganda."
Vietnamese authorities had frequently harassed Giang for his published
writings about corruption within the Communist Party. Giang's political
essays—which dealt with such issues as peaceful reform, multiparty democracy,
and human rights—regularly appeared on Internet sites and in newspapers
published by Vietnamese living in exile. His arrest followed a series
of articles in the government-controlled press arguing that dissidents
posed a threat to the state.
On May 10, 1999, Giang was released on bail after an international campaign
on his behalf. However, he remained under house arrest, and his activities
were closely monitored.
Ha Sy Phu, free-lancer
IMPRISONED: May 12, 2000
Dr. Nguyen Xuan Tu, a scientist and political essayist better known by
his pen name, Ha Sy Phu, was placed under house arrest and charged with
treason. The arrest came after an April 28 raid on Ha's home in Dalat,
Lam Dong Province, during which police confiscated a computer, a printer,
and several diskettes. They returned on May 12, with orders for his arrest
signed by Col. Nguyen Van Do, police chief of Lam Dong Province.
The case had its origins in official suspicion that Ha helped draft a
pro-democracy declaration, according to CPJ sources, and it followed on
long-standing harassment of the writer by the government. Ha was held
under Administrative Detention Directive 31/CP, which provides for indefinite
house arrest without due process, and was required to report daily to
the Dalat police for interrogation. Treason is punishable with the death
penalty.
Though the treason charge was not withdrawn, official harassment of Ha
Sy Phu had eased slightly by year's end. However, he remained under house
arrest.
|